Visitor
Score

amateur photography


Phil-Hand | Asked  over a year ago | Last response was 8 months ago
I am a bit confused. Not hard for an amateur in such a complicated field. I see that the Nikon D5100 has over 160 lenses that can be used whereas the Sony NEX_5 only has 8. However in the pros for the NEX it says that there is a built in focus motor. What advantage does that give to the amateur photographer? Also, I have the NEX-3 and bought a Sony telescopic lenses and an adapter but for some reason with the adapter I don’t have automatic focus capabilities. ??? I don’t want to get into a NEX-5 and have the same problem with the lenses. Anybody help me with these issues?

Which camera do you recommend for Phil-Hand?

Nikon D5100 - $497
16.1 MP|APS-C CMOS|3" LCD
Sony NEX-5 - $300
14 MP|APS-C CMOS|3" LCD
3 Answers
  1. Intermediate I
    cameras Community
    Fair Minded
    Score
    a year ago Ben-Marshall recommends both cameras

    You will only Have Autofocus, if the adapter AND the lens you use have Autofocus Capability.

    I personally own a NEX 3, and a Canon 50D.  I have Adapters for both to use LEGACY lenses, or lenses that were not made to be used on these cameras.  I prefer Manual focus for my Street Photography and Candids, But when its business time, Its Autofocus or the moment is gone.

    The difference that the NEX and the Nikon have, is that Nikon has been making lenses for the current line for over 10 years, the same electronics in the mount, and that leaves a lot of space for 3rd party brands as well.

    NIKON only advertises their own lenses, and there are at least 10 other Manufacturers that make lenses for Nikon as well... so that 160 figure is just the tip of the iceberg.

    Also, you really need to figure into the equation, the use you plan on getting from these cameras... Porsche makes some Great Sports cars, but if the speed limit in your state is 35, you could simply buy a Volkswagen. 

    This is not comparing the cameras, but the Lenses they have available... You can Easily spend $2,000 on a single lens for the Nikon, and really only need a $150 lens... meaning.... out of the 160 available, there are probably only 5 that might have any use for you... so basing your decision on that figure is useless.

    Reply
  2. Beginner II
    Nikon D5100
    Supporter
    Score
    8 months ago blargh recommends the Nikon D5100

    Take the DSLR because of the Viewfinder! Much sharper than Liveview. And using the viewfinder, the Camera can use the faster Phase-AF system!

    Reply
  3. Intermediate III
    cameras Community
    Fair Minded
    Score
    over a year ago WaterlooAlex recommends the Nikon D5100

    Hi Phil, these are both great cameras. I'd recommend the Nikon D5100 because there are so many more lenses and accessories available.

    The fact that the D5100 doesn't have a built in focus motor probably won't be an issue for you, this just means that the D5100 can't autofocus with older Nikon lenses. There are still a huge number of lenses it will autofocus with, including every new lens that Nikon produces. Nikon also is re-releasing new designs for many of its older lenses.
    1. Beginner II
      8 months ago blargh
      Especially get the Nikon because of the Viewfinder! I don't get how most people disregard this.... Also add phase detect AF, only avialable in DSLRs ...
    Reply