Beginner I
Score

Video capablities first, but appreciate still image quality as well.


alissahyoo | Asked  over a year ago | Last response was 5 months ago

Trying to make video shorts, but I enjoy taking photos just as much. Wish I could do the kill two birds with one stone kind of thing. I know the K-5 wins in most of the areas, but the T3i seems like a better option if I want to get into the video aspect. Any opinions?

Which camera do you recommend for alissahyoo?

Pentax K-5 - $699
16.1 MP|APS-C CMOS|3" LCD
Canon T3i - $549
17.9 MP|APS-C CMOS|3" LCD
18 Answers
  1. Beginner I
    Score
    over a year ago Teus-Renes recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    I have a K-5 and I'm extremely happy with pentax, but when video is your prime objective I should point you to the T3i because of the following.

    The camera offers Full HD 1080p video recording, as well as a complete range of aperture, shutter speed, and ISO controls in video mode.

    And if you want that film look of your footage you should keep the shutterspeed at 1/50 (which is closest to 1/48 which is 24p at 180 angle) Don't understand the last part?

    Reply
  2. Expert I
    cameras Community
    Fair Minded
    Score
    over a year ago Brenden-Sherratt recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    Canon makes a great camera, and a world class video camera as well.

    Reply
  3. Beginner I
    Score
    over a year ago aGuyFromPleven recommends the Pentax K-5

    Well, the K-5 is the better camera when it comes to photos, since its sensor is very close to that of a Nikon D7000. It's built better (weather-sealed, metal body, etc.) and you can mount old lenses (we're talking 40 years old or more) on it without an adapter, meaning you can get some pretty good photos and/or videos thanks to those lenses. I've got a K-r and I bought a 40 year old 50mm f1,7 very cheap. The 600D or T3i or how ever you want to call it is a good pick too, although not as well built. Canon's a more famous brand, that's why most people prefer it and recommend it. But trust me, you won't go wrong with the K-5, because it would most definitely blow the T3i out the water photo-wise. The only thing better with the T3i's video is that it's got a bit more frame rate options and a vary-angle display. Best thing for you is to go to the store and try them out. Good luck.
    Reply
  4. Beginner I
    Score
    over a year ago Ilker-Kostur recommends the Pentax K-5

    I've used Canon 1000D, 1100D, 450D, 500D and Nikon D3100 respectively. Now i m using a pentax k-x. this camera is unbelievable. great image quality, has the most vivid colors, video quality is better than others even it has 720p. microphone quality is the best of all. try this pentax in a crowded concert and get amazed with the sound recording quality. Pentax K-5 is far better. Will be my next camera if i will ever get bored of this k-x.

    Reply
  5. Intermediate I
    cameras Community
    Fair Minded
    Score
    over a year ago Marco-de-Boer recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    If it's video capabilties first, I would recommend the 600D. The 600D has so many cool things to make filmmaking easy and fun.

    - snapshots of 2,4,6 or 8 seconds automaticly glued together, handy if you don't have an editor program in the neighberhood

    - a lot of video modes to choose from.

    - digital zoom 10x without really lose of quality

    - and don't forget the swivel and tilt screen on the back for easy shooting in hard situations.

    For photo taking I don't think they are that much seperated from each other, but don't forget those delicious L lenses from Canon. The plastic fantastic for just 100 euro's, the 85mm f/1.8 etc etc.

    Reply
  6. Beginner II
    Score
    over a year ago gilgildner recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    K-5 is a great camera, but the T3i is almost unparalleled in video performance.

    Reply
  7. Beginner II
    Score
    over a year ago Aidan-Woods recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    I have the T3i, best decision ever made in terms of camera buying :) - like you, I also made my decision based on primarily wanting to have a really good video camera but it definitely takes amazing stills as well.

    Reply
  8. Intermediate III
    Canon 600D / T3i
    Evangelist
    Score
    over a year ago John-Kim recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    While the sensor found in K-5 is highly regarded (similar if not essentially same SONY made sensor as ones found in Nikon D5100 and D7000), T3i is no chopped liver.

    T3i has fold out monitor that is very useful when shooting video.  It has excellent photo image quality and your choice of "CURRENT" autofocus lenses are more compelling.  I'd save $300, get T3i and put the difference towards purchasing good lenses, including a wide-angle variety.  As for build quality, it is plenty good enough for most all consumers, unless you are a photo professional.

    Pentax (and also Sonys) has sensor based image stabilization system, whereas Canon and Nikon have lens based image stabilization system.   While it may be more cost effective with sensor based IS since none of the lenses specifically have to have the feature designed into each lens, in reality, lens based systems are more effective, giving greater latitude of stabilization.

    Reply
  9. Beginner II
    Pentax K-5
    Supporter
    Score
    over a year ago William-Pead recommends the Pentax K-5

    The Pentax K-5 is an exceptional camera for stills and for video.  And the price has dropped quite a bit from the original $1500.  Any K mount lens can be mounted and used on the camera, including legacy manual lenses.  It's a definite step up from the Rebel, which is more a competitor to Pentax's Kr camera.

    Reply
  10. Beginner I
    Score
    over a year ago Silvia-Centeno recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    i recommend this because i have a t2 and the quality is great, and it also have a lot of gadgets for you to make professional movies

    Reply
  11. Beginner II
    Score
    8 months ago Jeffrey-Penafiel recommends the Canon 600D / T3i

    if for video the canon would be better but for photos which is a main use of a camera k-5 is the best

    Reply
  12. Intermediate I
    Pentax K-5
    Promoter
    Score
    9 months ago svitekphotos recommends the Pentax K-5

    There is no real competition to be made here... Until you move up to full-frame cameras, the Pentax will be the best possible choices. (I've owned the T3i, and am now shooting with the K-5)

    The sound from the built-in mic is WAY better than the T3i, and the external input is dependant on the quality you buy. Even though you can't record anything other than 30fps in the stock Pentax firmware, there is a neat hack which allows you to control your frame-rate between 1fps and 90fps at 1080p...

    The sensor is much better as well: Better ISO performance, higher max ISO, and the pixels are a bit bigger. The Pentax also uses less compression in its video files (Memory cards are cheap these days) and the body is also fully weather sealed... a big bonus, especially given the price.

    Overall, if you want better than the K-5, you'll have to go into Nikon's FX and Canon's FF territory... (Canon 1D C)

    1. Beginner I
      6 months ago Teflon-Jon
      Could you elaborate on that 90fps hack or post a link with more info please?
    Reply
  13. Beginner I
    Score
    over a year ago Bosco-Staccato-Chan recommends the Pentax K-5

    Canon's white balance is likely better for portraits, but if not, i will suggest the K-5 than Canon, The K-5 even got a shake resistant system which save a lot on buying anti-shake lens than canon. and a better variety of old lenses for better color performance. 

    Reply
  14. Beginner II
    Score
    over a year ago Emric-Delton recommends neither camera

    I bough a Sony NEX-5n because of video capabilities and I have not been disappointed. The only thing to remember is that sensor will heat up quickly and camera will overheat and shut down after a while ( I think all dslrs have that issue). I found that out the hard way while shooting a dance recital... But I was covering with 2 cameras, which saved my bacon. For a video short where you control your takes and can pause btw scenes, that should not be an issue.
    1. Beginner II
      over a year ago Emric-Delton
      Another thing to consider: the lens is going to be a big issue in any choice you make. It has to provide very smooth zoom and be totally silent. Most kit lenses might be 'OK' for stills but suck when it comes to providing seamless zooming in or out of a shot. If you are going to shoot compelling video, you have to shoot dynamically, not statically. I would go to local store and try lenses before buying. Find out wich one can allow you to zoom slowly and imperceptibly. The 5n lenses were built for that and are very smooth and easy to handle while shooting. Mirrorless continuous focus performs fairly well as well considering it is contrast detection.
    Reply
  15. Beginner I
    Score
    over a year ago Dennis-Kussener recommends the Canon EOS 60D

    maybe the 60D is more your thing

    Reply
  16. Beginner I
    Score
    9 months ago nAcolz recommends the Panasonic Lumix DMC-GH2

    This camera rocks when it comes to video as well as stills. You can also hack the firmware to shoot up to 100MB/S video.

    Reply
  17. Beginner I
    Score
    5 months ago kjetil-pedersen-kj-ls recommends the Pentax K-5

    -The image quality

    -sensor stabilisation

    -more focus points

    -weather sealed

    -Compact with compact lenses (limited series)

    Reply
  18. Intermediate I
    cameras Community
    Fair Minded
    Score
    5 months ago noahsnellphoto recommends the Pentax K-5

    The K-5 is an amazing camera. However, I do not believe you will be able to get what you want from a DSLR. You can't really kill two birds with one stone, in this case. I would recommend you buy a high quality camcorder with camera capabilities. If video capabilities come first, I would not recommend a DSLR.

    Reply