Visitor
Score

Image Quality for Landscape Photography


Andreas-Marjoram | Asked  over a year ago | Last response was a year ago

I have the 50D which I use to it's limits. I am not a pro, so to justify the Price of the Mark III is difficult. The Mark II is quite in reach, however I struggle to invest in somehow "old" Technology. Any convincing advice? Tank you, Andreas

Which camera do you recommend for Andreas-Marjoram?

Canon 5D Mark II - $2,479
21 MP|Full frame CMOS|3" LCD
Canon 5D Mark III - $3,499
22.1 MP|Full frame CMOS|3.2" LCD
2 Answers
  1. Intermediate III
    cameras Community
    Fair Minded
    Score
    a year ago John-Kim recommends neither camera

    If you are considering full-frame sensor body like 5D Mk II and Mk III, you also need to consider will my current Canon lenses work with them?

    If they are EL-S designation, you can only use them on crop sensor bodies such as 7D, 60D (50D) and Rebel/Tx series.  They will NOT work on 5D.  Only EL lenses will work on both crop and full-frame sensor bodies.

    For your stated purpose, 5D MkII will work fine; it is however, old by DLSR standards as it came to the market at the end of 2008 and your concerns are valid.  That is the criticism leveled at 5D MkIII by the photographic community that Canon did not do enough in updating MkII.  I think it is an unfair assessment overall as I think MkIII is an excellent camera, however, it is not worth $500 over its rival Nikon D800.

    Canon did definitely improve the focusing system by borrowing the AF system from their flagship 1DX and made a host of other improvements to MkII.  Still, people are not convinced that it is worth nearly $1,500 in cost difference over MkII.  I do agree that $1,500 difference is steep but MKII's original announced price at the time of release was $2,700.    

    Maybe you should think out of the box and wait for the release of a new full freame sensor body if you are not in super hurry to upgrade ..... from NIKON.

    Yes, Nikon; they announced that they are releasing D600, a ful frame sensor body rumored to be around $2,000.  it would have Nikon's latest technology and is $1,500 cheaper than MKIII and cheaper than 4 yr. old MkII.  And Nikon has all types of lenses that Canon has in their lineup.

    Just curious what Canon lenses you have now ... if it is only a couple of lenses, and especially if any are EL-S designation, then swiching might be more practical than you think.  

    1. Visitor
      a year ago Andreas-Marjoram
      Thank you, John! I indeed was about to change to the Nikon system, however I have some pretty Canon primary EF lenses which I did not want to loose at all :-) So I made my move to the EOS Mark II, saving a lot of money which I now can invest in some other interesting things. I am quite happy with the Canon ergonomics, the operation of the MII feels just right. Thank you for the feedback anyway! Andreas from Germany
    Reply
  2. Beginner II
    Score
    over a year ago Hector-Dayrit recommends the Canon EOS 5D Mark II

    If you are shooting landscapes you will do more than fine with the 5D2 as the IQ of the 2 cameras at base ISOs are roughly the same. The 5D3 only wins out on speed, AF and slightly better IQ at high ISOs but if you are a landscape photographer I would assume you seldom venture to the ISO 6400+ territory anyway. 

    Don't be fooled by the hype. The 5D2 may be old but it still has a LOT of camera goodness in it. The full frame sensor will take your landscape shots to a whole new level. 

    But all things being equal, if you were able to hold on to your 50D and not upgraded since, you can reward yourself with a 5D3. If you can stick with it like you stuck with your 50D then the "joy" of owning and using one over the years is a good, justifiable investment in and of itself.   The 5D3 will enable you to go out of your comfort zone, should you wish to dabble in BIF and sports photography in the near future. 

    Vistaclues (Tony Northrup) has compared these two cameras in detail on YouTube. I suggest you check it out. 

    1. Visitor
      over a year ago Andreas-Marjoram
      Thank you Hector, this helps a lot. I am currently in favour of the MII and Spende the savings on other usefull stuff. You are right, if the need to reward myself for waiting is getting to strong, I may opt for doing something - well expensive but nice :-) Thank you! Andreas
    Reply