Compare with...

  • Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ200
  • Canon EOS 60D
  • Nikon D3100
  • Nikon D3200
  • Canon Rebel T3i
vs
Front view of Nikon D5100

Nikon D5100

Change »
$348
  • 18 MP
  • 33.8x f/2.8
  • 1/2.5" Backlit CMOS
  • 3" LCD
Released March, 2012
The quality of the standard panoramas is good but not fantastic.
Rated 72% by by DPReview (Apr, 2012)
 
$497
  • 16.1 MP
  • APS-C CMOS
  • 3" LCD
Released April, 2011
Here we look at the RAW files processed through Adobe Camera Raw (in this case version 6.4 beta).
Rated 76% by by DPReview (Apr, 2011)
 

Conclusion Which is better for you?

69%
85%
View Details
?
?
View Details
46%
45%
View Details
84%
83%
View Details

Winner

NikonD5100

59
66

Features Key features of the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V compared to the Nikon D5100

MP18

1/2.5"

Angle view of Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V
Image stabilization is fantastic.
Rated 80% by by W.-Linstrom (Apr, 2013)
Back view of Nikon D5100

16.1 MP

APS-C

JPEG shooters will love the ability to shoot with Active D-Lighting turned on with little penalty in noise levels (or continuous shooting performance) and more advanced users will enjoy the malleability of its NEF files.
Rated 76% by by DPReview (Apr, 2011)

megapixels

0 MP
18 MP

16.1 MP
20 MP
Still, its a lot of megapixels and if you're only printing 10x8 or smaller sized photos, this is more than enough with great quality at those sizes.
Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V by M.-Cordoba--mxc
The Nikon D5100 is a new 16.2 megapixel DSLR camera that can record Full HD movies at 1920x1280 pixels / 25fps with stereo sound.
D5100 by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)

sensor size

Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V
Nikon D5100
bigger/better. So image quality at 100% size is lower than those of a 10 mp camera with a similar sensor.
Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V by M.-Cordoba--mxc
I had purchased one of the Micro Four Thirds cameras because it was light and small, but I found the quality lacking when compared to APS-C cameras.
D5100 by Rob-LaRosa (Apr, 2011)

body size

122 x 87 x 93 mm
127 x 97 x 79 mm
It's lightweight, so it's easy to carry.
Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V by WV-Gal (Jan, 2013)
It is lightweight and reasonably easy to carry around.
D5100 by Carl-E.-Sims--BGANGA (Jun, 2012)

focus points

0
11

9
20
The faster focus is great, color, clerity is wonderful with excellent detail!
Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V by T-Lindsay (Oct, 2012)
Ultimately the Nikon D5100 easily overcomes its few real weak points, offering a compelling mix of great image and movie quality, precise and quick auto-focusing, accurate metering and a fantastic LCD screen, all in a format that most users will find intutive and enjoyable to use.
D5100 by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)
 

Performance Real world tests of Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V vs Nikon D5100

battery life

450 photos
660 photos
#34;. First of all, the battery life is far better than previous models.
Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V by Usagi3 (Feb, 2013)
One thing I forgot to add, the battery life is wonderful.
D5100 by Eleanor-Faye-Lewis--appy20

max continuous shooting

view all the time, it would be much easier to follow the action whether in burst or single shot mode.
Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V by YnotMe (May, 2012)
Continuous Shooting Speed: As you work your way up the Nikon dSLR line-up the cameras' continuous shooting speed and maximum shots at that rate increases.
D5100 by dojoklo
 

Differences What are the advantages of each

Advantages compared to the Nikon D5100

Image stabilization Optical vs None
Supports image stabilization
Create realistic 3D images Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Create 3D photos to view on a 3D TV
Includes a GPS Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Records the location of your photos automatically
Faster rapid fire 10 fps vs 4 fps
2.5x faster continuous shooting; Take photos in rapid succession to capture motion
Automatic panorama Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Stitches together multiple photos into a single ultra-wide view
Marginally more recently announced Feb, 2012 vs Apr, 2011
Announced date 10 months later
Higher resolution 18 MP vs 16.1 MP
More than 10% higher resolution; Capture more detail, good for large prints
More contrast-detection focus points 9 vs 0
9 more contrast detection focus points; Better autofocus in low light settings

Advantages compared to the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V

Significantly larger sensor APS-C vs 1/2.5"
More than 13x larger sensor; higher quality photos
Has a flash hot shoe Generic vs Fewer choices in how to light your subject
Very few cameras have a flash hot shoe; Connect a variety of external flashes for maximum lighting flexibility
Interchangeable lenses Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Use a variety of specialized lenses
Shoots RAW Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Adjust white balance and exposure more easily in post production
Shoots video in 24p Yes vs No
Somewhat common; For that film look
More photos per charge 660 vs 450
210 more shots; Longer battery life
Higher light sensitivity 25,600 ISO vs 12,800 ISO
2x higher light sensitivity; Avoid blur in low light situations
Self cleaning sensor Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Prevents dust showing up in your photos
More phase-detection focus points 11 vs 0
11 more phase detection focus points; Faster autofocus in reasonably lit settings
Thinner 79 mm vs 93 mm
Around 20% thinner

Reviews Word on the street

Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V

Nikon D5100

Rated 72%
Read the review (Apr, 2012)
On the back of the camera is a big and beautiful 3-inch articulating LCD display.
Rated 76%
Read the review (Apr, 2011)
In general though, judged on its own merits the D5100 is a satisfying camera, and as far as image quality is concerned it is most definitely a wolf in sheep's clothing.
Rated 90%
Read the review (Apr, 2012)
The Sony CyberShot DSC-HX200V's maximum shutter speed is 30 seconds in the Manual mode, which is great news if you're seriously interested in night photography.
Rated 90%
Read the review (Apr, 2011)
The Nikon D5100 lets you dial in shutter speeds of up to 30 seconds and has a Bulb mode as well for exposure times of practically any length, which is very good news if you are seriously interested in night photography.
Rated 88% by 201 users at amazon.com
Shooting movies and the ability to shoot a good sized still at the same time is very impressive - probably one of the best features - as I've always wanted to be able to take a high MP shot during a video shoot because that's when you typically need it and on other cameras it was always one or the other but not both at the same time.
Rated 100% by by TechGuy (Mar, 2012)
In summary it will never please the pro's out there - the image quality is very good but not perfect.
Rated 100% by by TechGuy (Mar, 2012)
Superior Auto intelligently detects 33 scenes for still images and movies, making it easy to get the best shot.
Rated 100% by by RosieAndMe (May, 2012)
Rated 90% by 645 users at amazon.com
The pictures taken by ths camera are splendid with nice color very-similarity to the real scenery.
Rated 100% by by Di (Jan, 2012)
Its portable, durable, has great quality my experience with this camera has only been a good one.
Rated 100% by by daniel (Feb, 2012)
I just used the Auto mode and took some pics and 1080p videos and they came out of the world.
Rated 100% by by sonu (Apr, 2011)

Discussions Get involved, ask your question about the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX200V and Nikon D5100

Sony
DSC-HX200V
Nikon
D5100

Select aspects that are most important to you: (max 3)

Popular tags:

Popular Questions

August 28, 2012
Upgraded to nikon d5100 w/ 55-200mm from sony cybershot hx100v :-(

I just upgraded to a Nikon D5100 from our daughter's tried and true Sony Cybershot HX100V.  I have an 18-55mm and am thrilled with the indoor portrait type pics, but am SO disappointed with all I...

Beginner I
8
Answers