Compare with...

  • Nikon D7000
  • Sony SLT A65
  • Pentax K-30
  • Nikon D5200
  • Nikon D3200
Front view of Sony SLT A57

Sony SLT A57

« Change
vs
Front view of Nikon D5100

Nikon D5100

Change »
Ranked #1 and #4 in non weather sealed DSLRs
$460
  • 16 MP
  • APS-C CMOS
  • 3" LCD
Released April, 2012
This combination means that the A57 can offer full-time DSLR-like focusing speeds, even during video recording, plus an excellent Live View system with 100% scene coverage and an amazingly fast continuous shooting rate of 12fps, whilst being physically smaller and lighter than a comparable DSLR.
Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
 
$497
  • 16.1 MP
  • APS-C CMOS
  • 3" LCD
Released April, 2011
All in all, though, the D5100 delivers excellent still and moving pictures with the minimum of fuss in a lightweight package and is a serious rival to the Canon EOS 600D and the Sony A55.
Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)
 

Conclusion Which is better for you?

97%
83%
View Details
61%
39%
View Details
93%
92%
View Details
92%
83%
View Details

Winner

SonySLT A57

82
77

Features Key features of the Sony SLT A57 compared to the Nikon D5100

MP16

APS-C

Back view of Sony SLT A57
Beside the AVCHD movie capabilities, I find it very nice that an internet-ready MP4 option at 3Mbps is available in addition to a 14Mbps MP4.
Rated 100% by by J.-Sullivan--J.-Sullivan (Jun, 2012)
Back view of Nikon D5100

16.1 MP

APS-C

D5100 superior low light excellent image quality and loving it more, I have returned my D3100 and keeping Nikon D5100 instead,using Nikon 35mm 1.8G AF-S ( same 1600 ISO and shutter, Aperture etc., clearly less noise under indoor night low light condition worth every penny IMHO).
Rated 100% by by Cebuano (May, 2011)

megapixels

0 MP
16.1 MP

16 MP
20 MP
The Sony A57 can shoot full-resolution 16.1 megapixel pictures at up to 12fps whilst maintaining continuous auto focus and auto exposure, an incredibly fast rate for such an inexpensive camera.
SLT A57 by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
The Nikon D5100 is a new 16.2 megapixel DSLR camera that can record Full HD movies at 1920x1280 pixels / 25fps with stereo sound.
D5100 by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)

sensor size

Sony SLT A57
Nikon D5100
The a57's APS-C sensor has comparatively good sized individual sensors, which is just one small part of all of the tech working together in the a57 to result in great video and picture quality.
SLT A57 by John (Feb, 2013)
I had purchased one of the Micro Four Thirds cameras because it was light and small, but I found the quality lacking when compared to APS-C cameras.
D5100 by Rob-LaRosa (Apr, 2011)

viewfinder size

Sony SLT A57
Nikon D5100
Size, it feels just right and comfortable in my hands.2- Bright 3 inches pivoting screen, that you can actually fold back when not using, thus protecting the screen.3- The EVF is excellent, bright and captures all the details.
SLT A57 by P.-Chebib (May, 2012)
Viewfinder: The D5100 has a pentamirror viewfinder with approximately 95% coverage of the actual resulting image, the same as the D3100.
D5100 by dojoklo

body size

132 x 98 x 81 mm
127 x 97 x 79 mm
The a57 feels solid and heavy, as one would expect.
SLT A57 by John (Feb, 2013)
It is lightweight and reasonably easy to carry around.
D5100 by Carl-E.-Sims--BGANGA (Jun, 2012)

focus points

0
15

11
20
As with Live View, continuous phase-detection AF is possible whilst shooting movies on the A57, a distinct advantage over most DSLR cameras and fast enough to rival Compact System Cameras like the Panasonic Lumix GH series.
SLT A57 by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
Ultimately the Nikon D5100 easily overcomes its few real weak points, offering a compelling mix of great image and movie quality, precise and quick auto-focusing, accurate metering and a fantastic LCD screen, all in a format that most users will find intutive and enjoyable to use.
D5100 by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)
 

Performance Real world tests of Sony SLT A57 vs Nikon D5100

DxOMark image quality

Sony SLT A57
Nikon D5100
Color, sharpness, noise control.....the a57 has EXCELLENT image quality.
SLT A57 by David-Melges--O-toole-fanatic (Apr, 2013)
Was very excited to get his camera in the mail and it was everything it said it was, the picture quality is great and I was VERY happy with this purchase.
D5100 by Kmimi00 (Feb, 2013)

DxOMark low light performance

Sony SLT A57
Nikon D5100
The handheld twilight mode also enables great night pictures without using tripod.
SLT A57 by Ong-Chi-Hang (Jan, 2013)
This is an excellent camera for those photographers who do low light shooting, The colors are brilliant and clear.
D5100 by Filmmaster-6 (Feb, 2012)

continuous shooting

12 fps
4 fps
I've never seen 10fps burst rate until this.
SLT A57 by S.-Aksenov (Mar, 2013)
Continuous Shooting Speed: As you work your way up the Nikon dSLR line-up the cameras' continuous shooting speed and maximum shots at that rate increases.
D5100 by dojoklo

battery life

550 photos
660 photos
The battery life on this camera is also outstanding.
SLT A57 by Jo (Mar, 2013)
One thing I forgot to add, the battery life is wonderful.
D5100 by Eleanor-Faye-Lewis--appy20
 

Differences What are the advantages of each

Advantages compared to the Nikon D5100

Much faster rapid fire 12 fps vs 4 fps
3x faster continuous shooting; Take photos in rapid succession to capture motion
Much higher definition video HD video vs HD video
Great video; great for displaying on a large flat panel TV
Image stabilization Sensor shift vs None
Supports image stabilization
Much bigger viewfinder 0.72x vs 0.51x
More than 40% bigger viewfinder size
Create realistic 3D images Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Create 3D photos to view on a 3D TV
Much larger viewfinder coverage 100% vs 95%
Around 10% larger coverage
Much more highly reviewed by consumers 92.19% vs 82.75%
More than 10% more highly reviewed by consumers
Automatic panorama Yes vs No
Somewhat common; Stitches together multiple photos into a single ultra-wide view
Marginally more recently announced Mar, 2012 vs Apr, 2011
Announced date 11 months later
More cross-type focus points 3 vs 1
Three times as many cross type focus points; Easier and faster focusing in low light
More phase-detection focus points 15 vs 11
4 more phase detection focus points; Faster autofocus in reasonably lit settings

Advantages compared to the Sony SLT A57

Significantly less noise at high ISO 1,183 ISO vs 785 ISO
More than 50% higher low light performance
Better overall image quality 80.0 vs 75.0
Around 10% better image quality
More photos per charge 660 vs 550
110 more shots; Longer battery life
Smaller 127 x 97 x 79 mm vs 132 x 98 x 81 mm
Around 10% smaller
Lighter 560 g vs 618 g
Around 10% lighter
Slightly thinner 79 mm vs 81 mm
Almost the same

Reviews Word on the street

Sony SLT A57

Nikon D5100

Rated 90%
Read the review (Jun, 2012)
The myriad of creative effect on offer such as HDR, Dynamic Range Optimisation, creative styles, the innovative sweep panorama mode and a new range of in-camera Picture Effects help to get the most out of the A57, especially if you like to experiment away from a computer.
Rated 90%
Read the review (Apr, 2011)
The Nikon D5100 lets you dial in shutter speeds of up to 30 seconds and has a Bulb mode as well for exposure times of practically any length, which is very good news if you are seriously interested in night photography.
Rated 94% by 87 users at amazon.com
Sony SAL-85F14Z 85mm f1.4 Carl Zeiss Planar T Coated Telephoto Lens for Sony Alpha Digital SLR Camera, Sony 24 -70mm f/2.8 Carl Zeiss Vario Sonnar T Zoom Lens for Sony Alpha Digital SLR Cameras, and Sony SAL-1680Z 16-80mm f/3.5-4.5 Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T DT Zoom Lens for Sony Alpha Digital SLR Camera)I have paired this camera with the very nice 16-80mm lens, but I have also been using the very inexpensive Sony 35mm F1.8 lens, and the images have been exceptionally good.
Rated 100% by by Ray--A-Reader (Dec, 2012)
It is the best focus assist system for manual focusing in the world.
Rated 100% by by N-Doxey
Autofocus is really fast, unlike nikon competitors you have built-in AF motor that you can use with old excellent minolta lenses.
Rated 100% by by Beka (Oct, 2012)
Rated 90% by 639 users at amazon.com
The pictures taken by ths camera are splendid with nice color very-similarity to the real scenery.
Rated 100% by by Di (Jan, 2012)
Its portable, durable, has great quality my experience with this camera has only been a good one.
Rated 100% by by daniel (Feb, 2012)
I just used the Auto mode and took some pics and 1080p videos and they came out of the world.
Rated 100% by by sonu (Apr, 2011)

video

The low light capability, short focal length of the 18X55 lens, huge sensor (comparative to camcorder) and enormous fun of playing with depth of field in video, and smooth realtime video autofocus make the a57 just hugely fun to plan and shoot video with, and there is a uniqueness to DSLR video shot with this feature set.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 100% by by John (Feb, 2013)
The A57 can record 1080p HD 1920 x 1280 pixel movies at either 50fps or 25fps (PAL), or 60fps and 24fps (NTSC) in the AVCHD format, or 1440 x 1080 pixels at 30fps/25fps in the MPEG-4 format, useful as this format can currently be shared more easily.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
The Sony SLT A57 is a fast, quality camera with impressive video capturing capabilities.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 80% by by Merto (Jul, 2012)

sensor

Noise doesn't rear its ugly head until ISO 3200 for JPEGs, although the A57 does apply some pretty aggressive noise reduction to keep the files clean, resulting in some loss of finer detail.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
The shooting speed is excellent, at least twice as fast as rivals and a57 has a HUGE BUFFER SIZE (21 raw+jpeg) that takes fast shooting experience to a higher level.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 100% by by Beka (Oct, 2012)
the resolution of the slt a57 is better at iso 3200 and above.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 100% by by luke (Apr, 2012)

lens

The A57's top plate features the aforementioned shutter release button encircled by an on/off switch that visually apes the zoom levers found on some compact cameras.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
Instead of a flipping mirror, the a57 uses a semi-transparent one that doesn't need to flip which enables this $700 camera to take rapid 8 (full control), 10 (aperture control), and all the way up to 12 (cropped resolution) frames per second.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 80% by by Merto (Jul, 2012)
If you know what you want from both a visual and a technical perspective and have the right lens for it, the a57 will get you there.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 100% by by John (Feb, 2013)

auto

If ISO set to auto then camera can choose any ISO 100 to max, Nikon D5100 we can set max ISO for auto ISO, this way we can instruct camera not to go beyond say 1600 ....* Kit lens focusing has difficulty focusing in some normal focusing condition.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 100% by by rik
From my experience, in auto (or auto+), the a57 rarely identifies the proper scene, rarely meters correctly except for really simple scenes or outdoor scenes with consistent lighting across the scene (not high contrast as mentioned above), rarely gets the iso right on indoor shots (in room lighting, it often chooses a really hi iso which will result in terrible noise, rather than pop the flash or lower the shutter speed).
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 60% by by newtosony2013 (Jan, 2013)
The Nikon D5100 also has ISO Sensitivity Auto Control, activated from the shooting menu.
Nikon D5100 | Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)

iso

The Sony A57 is a new SLT / DSLR camera with a 16 megapixel sensor, 12fps burst shooting, 50p Full HD movies, high-resolution viewfinder, 3-inch free-angle LCD and an ISO range of 100-16000, all for under £700 / $700 with a lens.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Jun, 2012)
Last the a57 will shoot at 16000 ISO which for all of us old film buffs translates to a lot of pushing in the darkroom.
Sony SLT A57 | Rated 100% by by Derrick (Apr, 2012)
The D5100 produces noise-free JPEG images at ISO 100-1600, with ISO 3200 also looking pretty good.
Nikon D5100 | Rated 90% by by Photography Blog (Apr, 2011)

Competition What else you should consider

Discussions Get involved, ask your question about the Sony SLT A57 and Nikon D5100

Sony
A57
Nikon
D5100

Select aspects that are most important to you: (max 3)

Popular tags:

Popular Questions

August 20, 2012
Nikon D5100 vs Canon Rebel T3i Vs Sony SLT-A57

Please can any unbiased expert tell me which is better : Canon T3i, Sony Slt A57 or Nikon D5100.. I want the best picture and Video.. Thanks

Visitor
34
Answers
August 14, 2012
Camera for HD video D3200, D5100, T3i, A57

I'm looking to film skiing primarily and already have a couple Nikon lenses.  Im really happy with the  Nikon ED AF-S VR-NIKKOR 70-200mm 1:2.8G Nikon ED AF NIKKOR 80-200mm 1:2.8 D I plan I...

Visitor
9
Answers
August 1, 2012
Difficult to decide? Sony Alpha 57? Nikon D5100? Canon EOS600D?

This is my first camera, could anyone give me some useful recommendations?

Visitor
8
Answers

Latest Questions

May 15, 2012
Taking great family photos and some outdoors

I have a canon sx20is and want to upgrade. My main focus is family photos and some outdoor ones. I want something other then a simple point and shoot. Any suggestions are greatly...

Visitor
1
Answers

Unanswered Questions

November 16, 2012
I need it to landscape and night images like moon and flowers and my f

I need it to landscape and night images like moon and flowers and my family ? 

Beginner I
0
Answers
November 2, 2012
A beginner interested in learning how to become a better photographer.

I'm debating between the Sony SLT A57 and the Nikon D5100 for my first good quality camera and I'm just wondering which one would be better to learn on, but would also last through learning the a...

Visitor
0
Answers
September 23, 2012
Canon 600d v Sony A57 v Nikon D5100

I'm looking to buy a DSLR for around £500. I've been to two camera shops and I'm still struggling between a canon 600d, Sony A57 and a Nikon 5100. I don't use video so that's not an advantage. I...

Visitor
0
Answers

Community What does Sortable's community think

39

vs

25

Sony SLT A57
Nikon D5100
 
60% of users recommend the Sony SLT A57 over the Nikon D5100
 

Sony SLT A57

aes-ace
cameras Community
Helper
Beginner II
I've had a Nikon D5100 and then I tried the Sony A57 and I can say it's big difference to use them. Sony is more comfortable, has quicker AF, better handling and controls.. Both have very similar... View aes-ace's recommendation
Nizar-Al-Sibai
cameras Community
Helper
Beginner I
Seeing as you're looking into beginner choices, you obviously don't have a collection of lenses that would limit your choices. That being said I'd say go ahead with Sony. They haven't been in the... View Nizar-Al-Sibai's recommendation
Jason-Byrne
cameras Community
Helper
Beginner II
A-57 vs Nikon D5100 The A-57 has: • Mirrorless Technology • Upto 16000 ISO (25600 with ISO Boost) • In-Built Image Stabilization • 12 FPS Burst Mode • More cross-type focus points • More •... View Jason-Byrne's recommendation

Nikon D5100

ukasz-Kwiatkowski
Beginner I
cameras Community
Helper
The best price, ease of use, great pictures, good high iso performance, relatively small as for dslr, i was considering t3i and d5100 (it took me almost 3 months to choose ) and i picked d5100.... View ukasz-Kwiatkowski's recommendation
Harri-Heikkil
Intermediate III
cameras Community
Fair Minded
Hi Natalie! Considering your priorities (family photos, general photography), Nikon D5100 is a slightly better choice. Sony is a better choice for action photographers / videographers. View Harri-Heikkil's recommendation
Philip-Davis
Expert III
cameras Community
Fair Minded
If image quality is your main concern then the D5100 is your best option.  It has the largest image sensor of the three cameras.  However, all three cameras are excellent choices for a your other... View Philip-Davis's recommendation

Browse All

Sony SLT A57 vs Nikon D5100 discussion

Browse